If you are looking for a high-quality cookware set, there is a high chance that you have seen the name All-Clad somewhere. All-Clad is one of the best manufacturers of cookware, whether you want one for home use or professional use. With different models, different materials, and different construction types, All-Clad makes cookware for almost every user.
A few years back, All-Clad released the D3 series, which became extremely popular because of its tri-ply construction. The tri-ply, or triple-ply, meant there were three layers of metal in the cookware which helped in more even heat conductance and durability. But the makers at All-Clad didn’t stop there. All-Clad then released the All-Clad D5 cookware set that has a Five-Ply construction.
In this article, we are going to compare two different models of the All-Clad D5 cookware set. We will compare the All Clad D5 Vs Copper Core. Both these models of cookware are part of the same Five-Ply series with some minor differences in construction. That is what we are going to discuss in this article. We will compare All Clad D5 Vs Copper Core, discuss their similarities and differences, and then see which one is the best option for you.
Table of Contents
All Clad D5 Vs Copper Core Comparison and Buying Guide
[amazon table=”1327″]There are plenty of differences between All-Clad D5 and Copper Core cookware sets. We would say that some of the differences are so significant that they will decide which one of the D5 vs Copper Core set should you be investing in.
Before we start discussing the differences and the similarities, we would just say that one of these is best for home use and the other is best for a professional kitchen. Keep reading to find out which is which.
All Clad D5 and Copper Core Key Difference
From the comparison table and the long-list of similarities, it seems like both these sets are quite similar, but there are some key differences between these two. Here are the key differences between All-Clad D5 vs. Copper Core, which might help you decide which one to buy.
Core Material
The most noticeable difference between the All-Clad D5 and Copper Core is the core material of the pieces. Both the All-Clad D5 and Copper Core have five layers, but the material of the layers differ. In the D5 cookware, the exterior layer is of ferromagnetic stainless steel, then comes the core layer, which is a sandwich between two layers of aluminum. Lastly, the fifth layer on the cooking surface is of food-grade 18/10 stainless steel.
On the other hand, in the Copper Core model, the rest of the FOUR layers are the same, but the core layer is copper instead of stainless steel. This is where the Copper Core set’s name comes from too. The copper layer is visible on the outside of the pans and pots of the Copper Core set too, which also enhances the outlook.
What does the difference in core material mean for the users? Well, the core material greatly affects heat conduction. When you turn on the stove and place a D5 saucepan upon it, it will require a longer time to heat up in comparison to a pan of the Copper Core set. This is because Copper is the core material. Copper is a better heat conductor than stainless steel.
So, while cooking in a Copper Core pan, you will have to be much more observant and proactive because the heat is reaching the food much more quickly. Usually, professional chefs prefer copper pans because they can handle the heat and need to prepare food as quickly as possible.
On the other hand, using a pan with the stainless steel core will take a little longer to cook because the heat travels at a slightly lower speed. For home cooks, the D5 pans are a better and safer option because you won’t be on your heels all the time.
Related Articles
- All Clad D3 Vs D5 Vs Copper Core
- All Clad D7 Vs Copper Core
- All Clad Ha1 Vs D3
- All Clad C4 Vs Copper
- All Clad D5 Vs D7
- All Clad 4112 Vs 41126
Appearance and Design
Aside from the layer of copper that is visible in the Copper Core pieces, there are other slight changes in the appearance and design of the D5 and Copper Core set. But first, we would just say that the copper line on the Copper Core sets looks beautiful. It just brings a tasteful contrast that makes the Copper Core look much better than the traditional and even the D5 cookware sets.
[amazon box=”B000MI3BD8″]The other difference is the design of the lid handles. The D5 has a square design of the handles on the lid, whereas the Copper Core has a round design. They both look very good, but we prefer the round design of the Copper Core. It is a bit more ergonomic, and it feels comfortable to use than the square design.
[amazon box=”B006ZNCMBQ”]Price
The prices of both these cookware sets from All-Clad might be a make or break for you. Ust the inclusion of copper as the core material lifts the price of the Copper Core by almost $200. The All-Clad D5 starts from $499 whereas, the cheapest 7-Piece model of the Copper Core will cost you about $950. The difference in the price again presses the point that the D5 is better suited for homes and the Copper Core is for professional chefs in restaurants.
All Clad D5 and Copper Core Similarities
From looking at the table above, you can tell that the D5 and Copper Core are more similar than different. Same construction materials, similar cookware pieces, and multiple other features are quite similar to each other. Let’s take a closer look at these similarities to see which one would be a better fit for your kitchen.
Cooking Surface
There is a difference in the core material, but the rest of the layers are the same. Most notably, the cooking surface is the same in both D5 and Copper Core. Both the D5 and Copper Core have a 304-grade stainless steel cooking surface that provides even heat to the food, is non-stick, and very durable.
With the basic stainless steel on the exterior and interior surface and aluminum layers in between, the overall construction of both D5 and Copper Core is quite similar. Although the Copper Core set cooks the food faster, the taste and texture of the food are the same because the heat distribution is even all across the cooking surface.
Lids and Handles
Good cookware needs to have strong and sturdy lids and handles to make cooking a bit safer and a bit easier. Thankfully, both the D5 and Copper Core sets have riveted handles and stainless steel lids with riveted handles. So, when cooking in pots and pans, you can easily take them off the stove, move them around, serve directly into plates, and put them back on the stove with ease without fear of burning your hands.
Similarly, stainless steel lids also play a huge role in keeping your food hot after cooking until you are ready to eat. But, the stainless steel handles on the lid mean you will have to use mitts to lift them because the lids and the handles do get a bit hot, especially when cooking for longer periods.
Cleanup
The stainless steel finish and the fact that both these cookware sets are dishwasher safe prove that cleaning the D5 and Copper Core pots after use is easy, but there is a catch. Even though they are dishwasher safe, All-Clad suggests cleaning the cookware manually. The reason for this caution is the corrosive dishwasher soaps.
When you clean these cooking accessories in a dishwasher, there is a high chance that the acidic dishwasher will damage the cooper lining and even stain the stainless steel exterior. Clean up of these cooking accessories by hand is very easy because they are non-stick with a stainless steel finish.
However, if you insist on using the dishwasher, make sure your dishwasher soap doesn’t have too strong substances like chlorine, lemon, or any other acidic materials. These materials can damage and stain the coatings, which will also affect the cooking performance later on. So, we would again say; wash it manually to prolong the life of the D5 and Copper Core cookware sets.
Oven-Friendly
Another similarity, thanks to the stainless steel exterior and the cooking surface, is that both D5 and Copper Core pots and pans are oven-friendly. As long as the temperature of the oven stays under 600F, you can broil and roast chicken pieces, burgers, steaks, and much more. The same goes for induction cooking. Just keep the temperature under control, and you can use these accessories on any cooking appliance. The Copper Core will even work with the electric stove.
Other Features
Both the All-Clad D5 and Copper Core cookware sets have a few useful features that enhance the user experience. It’s features like these that make All-Clad that much better than the rest of the cookware manufacturers.
- No Warping: One of the biggest complaints that chefs have with cookwares is that they start to wrap after some time. If you are going to spend the money on high-quality cookware, you will require longevity too. The careful engineering and bonding of the FIVE metal layers prevent warping, no matter how high temperatures you go to.
- Pour Rims: Usually, serving straight out of the pans and pots isn’t as straightforward as it seems. People often end up spilling more than serving inside the plate. But with the flared rims of the D5 and Copper Core cookware, you can easily serve without the fear of spillage and mess on the kitchen counter.
- Capacity Engravings: All the pots and pans of both the All-Clad D5 and Copper Core cookware have engravings on the bottom showing the cooking capacity of the said pot or pan. This allows you to cook with the right pan instead of using a 3 quarts pan to cook 1 serving of food.
Conclusion
To sum it all up, the All Clad D5 vs Copper Core comparison is a comparison of home vs professional cookware. The quality and the results are similar, but it is no secret that a professional cookware set will always be better than a home cookware set. If you are willing to spend the extra bucks, we would suggest the Copper Core, but the D5 cookware set is more than sufficient for any house use. As for a professional kitchen, the Copper Core is the obvious winner!
[amazon box=”B000MI3BD8″]
